[ASLML] A14.1

[morrisgj at mscd.edu]

Hello Janusz:

An example of when to take a "meaningless PTC" is B28.9 booby Traps - "Infantry normally immune to PTC must take them for Booby Trap resolution only, and their PTC cannot activate a Sniper".

Take care,

Gerry

----- Original Message -----
From: Janusz Maxe <janusz.maxe at unf.se>
Date: Monday, November 24, 2003 5:11 pm
Subject: [ASLML] A14.1

> The rule:
> 
> "Any such DR that can yield no game result other than a SAN is not 
> made (EXC: the DR required for an attack negated by blocked LOS is 
> made)."
> So what is a "game result"? I've always understood that this meant 
> "broken units don't roll for PTC", and "shot's miscalculated and 
> turning out to be a 2+5 don't roll".
> But now I'm not so sure any more. How about a roll that wil only 
> place a counter to be removed again (like PTC during AFPh against 
> a unit that has already fired, and is out of all possible CC, or a 
> shot to check LOS)?
> 
> Once, with my old regular opponent, we used to call a meaningless 
> PTC (during AFPh vs units out of possible CC) "SAN Task Check" 
> instead.
> Janusz Maxe
> Fältkonsulent Ungdomens Nykterhetsförbund
> Göteborgs och Bohusläns distrikt
> Fjärdelångg. 41
> 427 13 Göteborg
> tel: 031-14 33 60           mobil: 0733-838310
> e-post: janusz at unf.se
> 
> 
>